“The ‘Rating’ line on that form is meant for the judges only; it should not be construed as an additional comment on your story/poem.”
Um, just how would you interpret a C - ? It seems mighty clear to me and there's no way I can ignore it. At least it wasn’t marked in red ink.
88, +89, 51 ?
“Each judge chose a different rating style.”
I’ll just bet they did. Having worked with teachers who were trying to reach a consensus in matters of grading and assessment, I can picture a group of judges clinging to their individual approaches. What I can’t imagine is that the people running the contest tolerated it.
The form sent to the participants should not contain the rating portion of the feedback/evaluation forms.
I submitted a short story and an essay to a writing contest several months ago and received the response today. I appreciate the written comments. While I understand that the content of my work may not have appealed to certain readers, it is helpful when people take the time to provide feedback. Even if you don’t agree with them, they offer a fresh perspective and it is good to know if a section is unclear or an ending unsatisfying.
The comments from the C – judge were somewhat dismissive: “Slender tale featuring academic humor and – gasp! Hi-jinks – Caution: hard to write about boredom in an entertaining way.” I would agree that it is a slender tale, I actually like that description; it was never intended to be an in depth portrayal. And I appreciate the warning as a similar comment was made regarding an earlier draft of ALUMNI AFFAIRS in which the protagonist was tired in the opening chapter.
Writers are pushed to have that opening page sizzle. Grab the reader’s attention and RUN! But I think that depends on the theme and content of the story. I hate to see anyone get locked into a gimmick that they can't maintain; a reader can close a book at any point.
Last night I started reading a wonderful book, Lisa Tucker’s ONCE UPON A DAY. This is her opening paragraph:
“Stephen Spaulding was very happy, and you can’t say that about most people. He hadn’t sought happiness, but he recognized it. This was his gift: to know what he had.”
It isn’t frenzied, it isn’t outrageous; there are no aliens or vampires or anyone with an agenda to rule the world, get rich, or fall in love. There’s a guy who was once happy, and he is no longer happy because tragedy touched his life in a devastating manner. The voice is authentic; the novel opens in an effective manner. The character is engaging and his life is about to change.
Beginnings and endings are tricky, and, oh yeah, middles can be challenging also.
Another judge described my academic short story as ‘delightful’ and pointed out a couple of minor things I might want to add and delete, very helpful. The third judge commented that the story had “nice character details,” and told me to “keep writing!” Not so helpful—-which details did you like?
Along with the short story I submitted the essay I wrote about my father’s declining health and death. I’ve spent a lot of time tweaking this essay over the past four years. I know I have very little perspective on it because it remains so emotionally charged for me.
Vague comment: “A loving tribute.”
Thanks, but what worked, what didn’t work?
Somewhat helpful comment: “Touching story. Nice imagery. Ending could be stronger.”
I agree that the ending could be stronger. A few specifics would have been nice.
Possibly helpful: “. . . very moving recollections of a love for a father. I am a bit confused by the organization. I think an improvement would be to re-organize, using chronological order.”
I disagree regarding chronological order in this essay; however, if a reader was confused, that is a prompt for further consideration.
These judges were all tip-toeing in their responses because of the emotional nature of the essay. I imagine they had many entries to read so I applaud their ability to even make written comments.
I’m planning to volunteer to judge some of the entries in the very popular Romance Writers of America contests. I’m curious as to their rules and guidelines in streamlining this process and I find the sheer number of entries staggering. I know there will be novels that I may not care for, it is a far broader genre than people realize, but hopefully I will be a more sensitive reader due to my experiences.